According to Eurogamer.net, Microsoft’s Xbox division has released a new marketing campaign for Xbox Game Pass that completely misses the mark. The bizarre commercial attempts to draw a comparison between renting games from physical stores in the past and accessing games through Game Pass today. It features a man living inside a video store returns box who acts desperately grateful when someone returns a copy of Gears of War for Xbox 360. The ad then cuts to modern gaming setups with the tagline “This is how we play now,” suggesting Game Pass solves the supposed problem of limited game access from rental stores.
Sponsored content — provided for informational and promotional purposes.
What’s Actually Happening Here?
Look, I get what they were trying to do. Basically, they want to position Game Pass as the modern solution to game access. But the metaphor completely falls apart when you think about it for more than five seconds. The guy in the returns box is surrounded by games – he’s not the customer, he’s apparently working there? So why is he acting like he’s never seen a game before? And if he’s processing returns, he’d be seeing dozens of games daily. The whole setup makes zero logical sense.
Here’s the thing about actual video rental stores – they were awesome. You could browse shelves with friends, discover new titles, and yes, sometimes they’d be out of the hot new release. But you could rent multiple games at once for a set period. Game Pass doesn’t actually work like that at all – you can’t get all the new releases, and it’s a subscription model, not a per-rental fee. The comparison just doesn’t hold up.
This Reflects a Bigger Xbox Problem
And this isn’t just about one bad ad. It speaks to Xbox’s ongoing identity crisis. Microsoft keeps struggling to explain what Game Pass actually is and why people should care. They’re trying to sell convenience while completely misunderstanding what people actually loved about the experiences they’re referencing.
Remember when everyone was nostalgic for Blockbuster? That whole cultural moment where people missed the ritual of going to the video store? Xbox somehow managed to make that experience look miserable while failing to explain why their alternative is better. It’s a weird own-goal when they could have positioned Game Pass as the modern evolution of that social, discovery-driven experience.
Why This Marketing Miss Hurts
So who actually wins here? Nobody, really. PlayStation doesn’t need to do anything – Xbox is doing the work for them. The ad makes Game Pass look confusing rather than appealing. And in a market where subscription fatigue is becoming real, you’d think Microsoft would want to make their value proposition crystal clear.
I mean, seriously – what’s the takeaway supposed to be? “Remember when you had to live in a returns box and kiss game cases? Now you can pay monthly!” It’s such a bizarre angle when the actual benefits of Game Pass – immediate access to hundreds of games, day-one releases, cloud gaming – are right there. Instead we get… whatever this is.
The whole thing feels like it was designed by committee, with everyone adding their “creative” touch until the original message got completely lost. In trying to be clever and nostalgic, Xbox ended up with an ad that confuses more than it convinces. And in today’s crowded gaming market, that’s a luxury they really can’t afford.
